Women's Fashions and Christian Modesty
>> Thursday, November 19, 2009
by Fr. Regis Scanlon
(Originally published in Homiletic and Pastoral Review, November 1988)
Author's Introduction: I wrote this article back in 1988 alerting the Catholic people to a landslide of immodest fashions coming our way. Time has shown that this article was correct. The fashions keep getting bolder and bolder. This article is even more relevant today than it was in 1988.
Red blooded American males had to notice the 1988 spring fashions for women which exposed the thigh and called attention to other feminine parts of the woman’s body. This new apparel was so bold that Newsweek editors claimed” “It Couldn’t be Worse for Wear.”1 Only the fall fashion lineup will tell the story. Whatever the case, it is high time that the Church in the United States begin teaching clear moral principles about modesty in relation to women’s dress. The Church must do all in her power to make sure that the mini skirts, “Hot Pants,” slit skirts, tight jeans, etc. of the 1960's and 1970's do not return and/or remain to plague society in the 1990's and beyond.2 The promiscuity that accompanied the introduction of these immodest fashions into our American society is still with us today. This article, therefore, is an attempt to point out fundamental principles for a concept of Christian modesty in relation to women’s dress and to respond to some of the objections by Catholics who see no hope for a clear concept of modesty in dress after the sexual revolution.
Before proceeding to discuss some of the objections to a clear concept of Christian modesty in dress after the sexual revolution, a couple of comments about the nature of this article and its topic are necessary. It should be common knowledge that there is a difference between male and female when it comes to sexual arousal in relation to fashions. The mere physique of an attractive woman can easily and immediately sexually excite the healthy red-blooded man, but the reverse does not normally seem to be the case. In the area of sexual stimulation, the male appears to respond immediately to the body of the female, but the female tends to respond gradually within the male/female relationship. The man, therefore, is more vulnerable than the woman when it comes to sexual stimulation caused by fashions.
Because the man is more vulnerable than the woman, especially in the area of sexual stimulation from women’s fashions, the male ought to be more sensitive to the question of modesty in relation to women’s apparel – at least if the man is honest about his own weakness and the problems that certain feminine styles can cause for him. Consequently, this author believes that the question of modesty in relation to women’s fashions can be best addressed by the man. To be sure there is also such a thing as modesty in relation to men’s clothing, and the author invites some courageous woman to treat this subject as a complement to his own article since he is also convinced that the Church would benefit most by a woman’s perspective on modesty in relation to men’s fashions.
Modesty is joined with chastity
The meaning of the concept of modest in this article does not simply refer to modesty in dress in general, but rather it refers specifically to sexual modesty in relation to women’s fashions. It refers to the wearing of clothes insofar as these clothes conceal and reveal those parts of the body which determine a woman’s sexuality. As such, this virtue of modesty is directly ordered to the virtue of chastity. In fact, “St. Thomas Aquinas treated modesty (pudicitia) as part of chastity, not a distinct virtue from it” (S.T., 2a2ae, 151.4).3 Within the context of Christian ethics, then, modesty in the area of sexuality shares in the nature of chastity. It is precisely because of this identity of modesty with chastity that the author defends the moral position that, like chastity, modesty in the area of sexuality is an absolute value which can never be violated by anyone in any situation.4 Practically, this means that just as fourth century St. Agnes and twentieth century St. Maria Goretti were obliged to give up their very lives rather than permit men to use their bodies for the sake of pleasure, so the Christian woman today must never violate sexual modesty by means of her dress even at the expense of her own life.
Let us now consider some of the arguments that discourage modern Catholics from taking a firm stand on the issue of modesty in relation to women’s dress.
Some Catholics today believe that the Church should not hassle the young about modesty in dress because they think that it is only a marginal Catholic teaching. But the first thing that was recorded in Sacred Scripture about Adam and Eve after their fall from Original Innocence was that they realized that they were “naked” (Gen. 3:7). By having Adam state: “‘I was afraid, because I was naked, so I hid myself.’‘ (Gen. 3:10), the author of the sacred text emphasized the importance of shame as a warning against the weakness in all human beings (especially in the man, Adam) in controlling their sexual desires. Following this, the author said that Adam and Eve made “loincloths” out of leaves for themselves and, later, God make “leather garments” for them (Gen. 3:7, 21). The fact that the author of the sacred text singled out this particular weakness in Adam and Eve in controlling their sexual desires and God’s consequent clothing of them as protection against this weakness, shows the importance in the area of sexuality of modesty in dress for all human beings and for all times.5
St. Paul had man’s weakness in controlling his sexual desires in mind when he recommended modesty of the body, especially with regard to those parts that determine one’s sexuality. When describing the human body as an analogy to the Church, the Apostle stated:
We honor the members we consider less honorable by clothing them with greater care, thus bestowing on the less presentable a property which the more presentable already have. God has so constructed the body as to give greater honor to the lowly members, that there may be no dissension in the body, but that all members may be concerned for one another. (Cor. 12:23-25).6When St. Paul called certain parts of the human body “less honorable” or “less presentable” or “lowly,” he was not saying that these parts of the human body are evil. He called them “less honorable” or “less presentable” or “lowly” only because fallen man perceives them as such, due to a sense of shame in relation to these parts of his body. And this is so because fallen man, whose will has been weakened byOriginal Sin, has a most difficult time controlling the powers related to these parts of his body (i.e., sexual powers). One might say that fallen man feels shame about these parts of his body because they seem so unruly.7
But this shame, which is an echo of man’s Original Innocence, begets respect for one’s body. Thus, St. Paul says that we cloth the “less honorable” parts of the body to give them more honor or make them more presentable so that there will be no dissension in the body. In other words, the fallen human being must treat those parts of the body which determine masculinity and femininity with more modesty so that man will control his body in holiness and honor rather than fall into the slavery of sex obsession. Far from being a marginal Catholic teaching, this “control of the body in holiness and honor” (modesty) is precisely what is essential for the virtue of purity.8
The necessity in the area of sexuality of modesty in dress can also be deduced from a very clear and firm teaching of our Lord Jesus Christ. Our Lord stated:
You have heard the commandment, “You shall not commit adultery.” What I say to you is” anyone who looks lustfully at a woman has already committed adultery with her in his thoughts (Mt. 5:27-28).If the man is bound by Divine Law to avoid impure thoughts about the woman, then it is only reasonable that there exists a reciprocal serious obligation on the part of the woman not to dress in such a way as to occasion or provoke these impure thoughts in the man (and vice versa).
One could, no doubt, give other reasons to support the argument that modesty in dress is a serious matter for the Christian. It should be adequate, however, to point out that the National Conference of Catholic Bishops of the United States taught that, in the area of sexuality, the teaching of modesty in dress is one of the “Basic Teachings For Catholic Religious Education.”9 In the area of sexuality, then, modesty in dress is not an optional or marginal matter for the Christian, but rather an absolute moral requirement.
Modesty is not prudery
Because traditional Catholic teaching on modesty in the area of sexuality requires the woman to keep more of her body concealed that it does for the man, some Catholics believe that it is unfair to the woman. While it is true that traditional Catholic teaching on modesty in the area of sexuality is more demanding of the woman, it is not unfair. Just as the woman is the weaker gender in the area of physical power, so the man is the weaker gender in the area of sexuality (in the sense that the male is more prone to immediate sexual arousal). And just as it is wrong for a man to use his physical strength to lord it over the woman, so it is wrong for a woman to use the feminine characteristics of her physical body to dominate a man. If the man must restrain his physical power so as not to bully the woman, the woman must restrain (conceal) the feminine characteristics of her physical body so as not to seduce the man. It is hardly a mere coincidence that when women refuse to dress modestly, men will often refuse to restrain their physical power over the woman in the matter of sexuality (rape). While the male and female gender each entail a special responsibility in the context of fallen human nature, if both responsibilities are met, justice and peace prevail.
There are also those Catholics for whom the very mention of the word “modesty” elicits a look of disdain. These Catholics scorn the subject of modesty in dress because they confuse it with prudery. But, modesty has nothing at all to do with prudery.
Prudery consists in concealing one’s real intentions with regard to persons of the other sex, or with regard to sexual matters in general. A prudish person intent on exploitation tries to make it appear that he has no interest at all in such matters – indeed he is prepared to condemn all, even the most natural, manifestations of sex and sexuality.10The modest person, on the other hand, is straightforward about the fact that every person has concupiscence which is a weakness, an inclination, or a wish to enjoy sexual values with no regard for the value of the person. While the modest person considers sex as being good, she also knows that it can be abused. Consequently, the modest person takes measures to protect herself and others from this admitted weakness by concealing those parts of her body which arouse concupiscence in the opposite sex.
The difference between modesty and prudery is quite clear. While modesty recognizes that sex is very good, prudery pretends that sex is evil, and, while modesty conceals the body, prudery conceals the intention. The essential differences between modesty and prudery, then, is that modesty is honest, but prudery is not.11
Perhaps the greatest difficulty is getting many Catholics to consider a firm stand on modesty in dress is that many Catholics think that an absolute norm in this area means an absolute skirt length regardless of the situation. But, it is necessary, here, to consider the functional differences in clothing. There are even situations in which total nudity may be justified since the function of the nakedness is not to stimulate to sexual pleasure. Thus, a person may expose his or her body totally for a doctor's examination or partially for labor or swimming. But, if one were to wear a particular outfit outside of the context for which the particular attire was designed, the particular clothing would be judged as immodest. For instance, it may be decent to wear a bathing suit for swimming, but it would not be decent to wear it down main street or at the shopping center. Or, one might be justified in wearing racing shorts that expose portions of the thigh in a sporting event, but it would not be modest to wear this apparel lounging around the college social center, or for casual wear at the parish or school picnic.12
The rule of functional difference in clothing can now be applied to specific instances of abbreviated and tight clothing. What was the function, for example, of the mini or micro-mini skirt, slit skirt, “Hot Pants,” tight jeans, etc. of the late 1960's and 1970's? It is important here to note that when these types of clothing flooded the fashion market during the beginning of the sexual revolution, the creators and producers of these items did not hide the fact that these kinds of clothing functioned specifically to excite the sexual passions of the male. Popular national journals carried numerous articles explaining that these items of clothing were blatantly “provocative” and “sexy” and functioned to satisfy the “pro-leg passion” of men.13 About the slit skirt, for example, one article on fashion design pointed out:
The philosophy behind exposure is basically the old peekaboo as most women seem to relish the sexy, lean-leggy style. And men are finding the slit a form of instant gratification.14Producers of this provocative apparel used the fact of their sexy function to market the product. This was expressed clearly in one Newsweek's article by David Gelman when he said:
The Jordache jean company, for example, hypes its contour-explicit pants by picturing scantily clad teenagers (boy and girl) astride each other in such proper media as the New York Times Magazine.15It is certain, then, from the fashion designers and producers themselves that the specific function of these abbreviated and tight-fitting forms of clothing for women is precisely to give immediate sexual satisfaction to the male. Christian women who wear these types of clothing may claim that they do not intend to cause phantasies in the male, but they cannot argue about the fact that this is precisely the function of this apparel.
The style’s function is the key
The same must be said for certain formal dresses and evening gowns worn, for example, at high school proms and weddings. What is the function or formal dresses and gowns that reveal the back, shoulder, and or nearly the breasts of women? There seems to be no other function of this exposition of the body than to enhance the woman’s attractiveness. But to attract the man by appealing to his desire for the flesh or body is precisely what contradicts the Christian sexual ethics. Because there is no worthy function of this exposure of the back, shoulders, and nearly the breasts in this context, these styles of women’s clothing are immodest.
Since there is no good reason for athletics and recreation to be an exception with regard to morality, one can have decent or indecent recreational attire. One must ask whether the sports attire is more revealing than need be for the function. One certainly has to wear less clothing for running a race and for swimming, but it hardly seems necessary that this clothing should be so snug or that the body should be exposed so far up the thigh as, for example, in groin cut jogging shorts or in French cut and Bikini swim suits. On November 8, 1952, Pius XII had this to say about the matter:
There is, moreover, in sports and gymnastics, in rhythm and dance, a certain nudism which is neither necessary nor proper. Not without reason did an impartial observer remark some decades ago: “What is of interest to the masses in this field is not the beauty of the nude, but the nudity of beauty.” The religious and moral sense places it veto on such a manner of practicing gymnastics and sports. In a word, gymnastics should not command and dominate, but serve and help. This is their duty and in this do they find their justification.16Secondly, one must ask whether the band or pep dress is more revealing than need be for the function. What is the function of the cheerleader and pompon girl’s mini or micro-mini skirt and short shorts? What is the function of the baton twirler’s groin cut body suit? Since it is possible to perform these athletic or pep routines quite well in Bermuda shorts or knee-length walking shorts, one must ask: What is the function of this abbreviated and tight clothing?
The Christian must understand that because chastity is an absolute value, it is never permitted to provoke sexual desires in a member of the opposite sex (other than one’s marital partner) by means of one’s apparel. The Christian, therefore, is forbidden to wear clothes in public that reveal or accentuate the body, “particularly those parts of it that somatically determine masculinity and femininity.”17
While there are certainly different degrees of immodesty, the seriousness of the immodest act in regard to dress is determined by the proximity of the revealed or accentuated part of the body to those parts of the body that determine a person’s masculinity or femininity. It is true that relative factors do enter into the consideration of the modesty of a certain dress, but if one should arrive at the conclusion that a certain dress functions to arouse concupiscence in a member of the opposite sex, then one is absolutely forbidden to wear it in public. Pius XII had this to say about modesty and fashions:
Yet no matter how broad and changeable the relative morals of style may be, there is always an absolute norm to be kept after having heard the admonition of conscience warning against approaching danger: style must never be a proximate occasion of sin.18Christians need to be aware that today, as at the time of Pius XII, outdated sophisms are used in an attempt to justify the wearing of skimpy and revealing clothes.
One of these resurrects the ancient saying ab assuetis non fit passio (“The passions are not around by things we are accustomed to”) in order to brand as old-fashioned the rebellion of honest people against fashions which are too bold.19Is it really necessary to show how out of place such ancient sayings are with regard to the modern question of modesty in dress?20 If “The passions are not aroused by things we are accustomed to,” then how does one account for the modern fact that men who buy pornography or X-rated videos are usually seen coming back for more? The ancient saying cannot stand up against modern knowledge about sex addiction or pastoral knowledge about habitual sin in the area of sexuality.21
“It is often said almost with passive resignation that fashions reflect the customs of a people.”22 While implying that the morality of fashions is totally relative, this sophism also denies the possibility of moral progress among people. But, it would be more to the point to say that customs reflect the decision of a nation to go in a moral direction: “. . . either to be shipwrecked in licentiousness or maintain itself at the level to which it has been raised by religion and civilization.”23
One more argument yet to be heard is that one should not teach modesty in dress until after one has throughly convinced children of the value of chastity. The aim here is to reduce modesty in dress to secondary or little importance. But it has already been pointed out that modesty in the area of sexuality is really part of chastity. Because modesty is the “natural bulwark” and “effective rampart” to chastity, it is really the border or beginning of chastity.24 Modesty is the child’s first step in chastity, just as honesty is the child’s first step in truth. Now it is irrational and even cruel to require children to fulfill subsequent and more difficult steps in a particular virtue without first helping them to master the initial and easier steps. To teach children the value of chastity without requiring them to be modest, makes about as much sense as trying to teach them the value of truth without requiring them to be honest.
One often hears Catholics say that it is useless to teach modesty in dress to out Catholic children today since there is no way to prevent immodest fashions from spreading to our young Catholics in a sex-saturated society. But, before the Christian abandons the virtue of modesty in dress to moral defeatism, he should admit that it is one thing for children to be encouraged toward immodesty by the secular society, and quite another thing for children to be encouraged to be immodest by their pastor, parent, or teacher. A child’s respect for his pastor, parent, and teacher can be strong enough that the example of modesty coming from the Church, home, and school will influence him more that the scandal of immodesty found in the sex-saturated society. While there will always be instances of immodesty in dress among the young, it is indispensable that Catholic institutions (parish, family, and school) never explicitly approve of the slightest degree of immodesty or condone it implicitly through silence. To do so would be to blind the child to the truth, and make it impossible for the child to ever reach to goal of Christian modesty.
No one is saying that it will be easy for the young to follow the Christian teaching on modesty in dress in a sex-saturated society. The young will have to abandon their pampered American life style and give up something temporarily, or even permanently, to be saved (i.e., public swimming, movies, videos, or even pep activity). They will find that life goes on without these things and is even more joyful. Nor is anyone expecting it to be easy for pastors, parents, and teachers to enforce Christian standards of modesty in behavior and dress among the young today. Pastors, parents, and teachers will find that getting children to do good and avoid evil today requires a struggle. Through the centuries, however, Christians have never considered the difficulty of the moral law justification for abandoning it. On the contrary, our National Conference of Catholic Bishops themselves stated quite clearly:
The Christian must know that there are moral values which are absolute and never to be disregarded or violated by anyone in any situation. Fidelity to them may require heroism of the sort which we see in the lives of the saints and the death of martyrs.25Modesty in the area of sexuality is one such moral value.
So modesty in dress is possible today if Christians have the courage to sacrifice and to change a culture in which it is normal (but not healthy) to be immodest. Modesty in dress will be a reality in the future Catholic Church in the United States if Catholic pastors, parents, and teachers genuinely accept out National Conference of Catholic Bishops’ teaching that:"In the area of sexuality, the Christian is to be modest in behavior and dress. In a sex saturated society, the follower of Christ must be different."26
The thoughts of Pius XII about the difficulty of being modest in a secular society are more appropriate today than when the Pope first stated them in the 1950's. About modesty and fashions, Pius XII said that Christians must not be trapped by the timidity which caused the numerically small but heroic armies of the great Judas Maccabeus to say: “‘How shall we, being so few, be able to fight against so great a multitude?’” (1Macc. 3:17).27 Rather, the Pope said, Christians must be encouraged by the same answer that was given to the great Judas Maccabeus: “‘For the success of war is not in the multitude of the army, but strength cometh from heaven’” (1Macc. 3:19).28
----------------------------------------------------
1. "It Couldn't be Worse for Wear," Newsweek.(November 23, 1987), 74.
2. "Autres temps, autres minis: Acceptable OfficeDress," Newsweek, 72 (July 22, 1968),62; "Hot Pants:Legs are Back," Time, 97 (February 1, 1971), 48; "Fashions '71: Anything Goes," Newsweek, 77 (March29, 1971),68-78, esp. 68; David Gelman et al, "The Games Teen-Agers Play," Newsweek, 96 (September I, 1980),49; "(peekaboo) The Thighs Have It: Skirts," Newsweek, 93 (June 4, 1979), 3, 88.
3. O'Riordan, "Modesty," New Catholic Encyc1opedia, vol. 9 (New York: McGraw Hill, Bk. Co.,1967), p. 997.
4. Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith, "Declaration on Certain Questions Concerning Sexual Ethics," No. 4-5 (Washington D.C.: United States Catholic Conference, 1976), pp. 5-6.
5. John Paul II, "Paul's description of the body and the teaching on purity," L'Osservatore Romano (February 9, 1981), 7.
6. Ibid., pp. 7, 22.
7. Ibid.
8. Ibid.
9. National Conference of Catholic Bishops (United States), "Basic Teachings For Catholic Religious Education," No. 19 (Washington D.C.: United States Catholic Conference, 1973), p. 21.
10. Karol Wojtyla, Love & Responsibility (New York: Farrar, 1981), p. 188.
11. Ibid., pp. 189-192.
12. Ibid., pp. 191-192.
13. Footnote 2.
14. Footnote 2, "(Peekaboo) The Thighs Have Il: Skirts," pp. 3, 88.
15. Footnote 2, David Gelman, p. 49.
16. Pius XII, "Sports and Gymnastics," Catholic Mind, 51 (September, 1953), 572.
17. John Paul II, "Paul's description," p. 22.
18. Pius XII, Di gran cuore, November 8, 1957, The Pope Speaks, vol. 4, p. 280.
19. Ibid., p. 284.
20. Ibid.
21. Patrick Carnes, Ph.D., The Sexual Addiction (Minneapolis, Minnesota: CompCare Pub., 1984),
22. Pius XII, Di gran Cuore, p. 280.
23. Ibid.
24. Ibid., p. 275.
25. National Conference of Catholic Bishops, no, 17, p. 18,
26. Ibid., no. 19, p.21.
27. Pius XII, Di gran core, pp. 284-285.
28. Ibid, p.285
0 comments:
Post a Comment