America Can Still Be Saved

>> Sunday, August 30, 2009

by Fr. Regis Scanlon, O.F.M.Cap. 

During the 1950's the media portrayed heroes who would sacrifice themselves rather than taking advantage of women or scandalize children. Recall Alan Ladd’s role in the1953 movie, Shane, and Gilbert Roland’s role in the 1952 movie, Our Lady of Fatima. In those days men were willing to risk their lives to defend or protect a child, a woman, or an elderly person. I can also remember at that time seeing many people in the Saturday confessional line at Church. Many went to confession on Saturday but not everyone went to Holy Communion at Sunday Mass. A number of people felt that they were not worthy to receive. This was a time of “Holy” Communions and a time that life and love flourished within the Catholic Church and the American society.

But was the connection between Holy Communions and growth in life and love in the Church and America in the1950's just a coincidence, or was there a necessary relationship between them? The aim of this article is to see if there is a necessary relationship between Holy Communions and the growth of life and love in the Church and society. If there is, perhaps we can discover a way to help today’s scandal ridden Church in the United States rise from its fallen state. Then the Church can lead America out of the swamp of licentiousness to new meadows of life and love.

In order to grasp what happened in the Catholic Church and in America following the 1950's one must keep in mind certain truths about the mystery of God and the mystery of human sexuality. First of all, Jesus referred to Himself in St. John’s Gospel as The “Bread of Life” and St. John says in his epistle that “God is Love” (Jn. 6:48; 1 Jn. 4:16). Jesus is the “Bread of Life” and Love which we receive in Holy Communion. This is He who is the source of all Life and Love.

Second, God created human sexuality to help people become holy and come to God. The Bible says that God created the first man and woman in the “image” of God and told them to: “Be fertile and multiply” (Gen. 1:27-28). Then, the Scriptures say that “a man leaves his father and mother and clings to his wife, and the two of them become one body” (Gen. 2:23-24). John Paul II maintains in Evangelium Vitae that “The meaning of life is found in giving and receiving love, and in this light human sexuality and procreation reach their true and full significance.”1 The purpose of human sexuality, therefore, is “life” and “love.” So, every time the Catholic Church teaches her doctrine on human sexuality, she proclaims Jesus Christ’s Gospel of Life and Love.

Because the Bread of Life and Love is inseparable from the Gospel of Life and Love, a complete proclamation of the Gospel of Life and Love will necessarily involve devotion to the “Bread of Life” and Love or the Blessed Sacrament. One should expect that the more devotion to the Blessed Sacrament increases in the Church, the more life and love will flourish among members of the Church and society. Similarly, an attack upon the Blessed Sacrament will be an attack upon life and love as it exists among the people in the Church and society.

A Radical Change

The Gospel of Life and Love had been growing steadily in America up to and through the 1950's. Purity, chastity, charity and peace were being promoted at all levels in society. The days of innocence, however, ended in the United States following the 1950's with the arrival of the sexual revolution. Public schools adopted explicit classroom sex education programs where teachers and students discussed, described, and even visually represented sexual acts with physical objects. Sexual activity erupted among the young at this time and increase exponentially thereafter. Today, most young people in America have in some way encountered pornography, contraception, divorce and remarriage, adultery, fornication, premarital sex, homosexual acts, and abortion.

This attack on human life and love following the mid 1960's and during the early 1970's was world-wide. Paul VI sensed the oncoming landslide of immorality. He tried to check it in 1968 by issuing his encyclical, Humanae Vitae. The Pope taught that contraception, or any act “intended to prevent procreation” for any reason whatsoever, is “intrinsically dishonest” and must be “absolutely excluded” by every Catholic.1 He warned that there would be grave consequences for humanity if contraception was socially accepted. The acceptance of contraception could “lead to the way being opened to marital infidelity and a general lowering of moral standards.”2 The Pope also stated that
man, growing used to the employment of contraceptive practices, may finally lose respect for the woman and, no longer caring for her physical and psychological equilibrium, may come to the point of considering her as a mere instrument of selfish enjoyment, and no longer as his respected and beloved companion3
Finally, he warned that, if people do not oppose contraception, civil governments “may even impose their use on everyone.”4

Paul VI’ teachings and warnings were not embraced by Catholics in the United States who continued to practice contraception and at the same time to receive Holy Communion. The American Bishops were confounded by the number of people approving of contraceptives and receiving Holy Communion. The bishops got their chance to discuss this matter with John Paul II when he came to the United States and met with the bishops in California on Sept. 16, 1987. Archbishop John R. Quinn of San Francisco, speaking on behalf of the bishops, stated to the Holy Father: "We as pastors are greatly concerned that some particular areas of the Church's teaching in both sexual and social morality are at times subjected to negative criticism in our country and sometimes even by Catholics of good will."5 John Paul II replied:
It is sometimes reported that a large number of Catholics today do not adhere to the teaching of the Church on a number of questions, notably sexual and conjugal morality, divorce and remarriage. Some are reported as not accepting the Church's clear position on abortion. It has also been noted that there is a tendency on the part of some Catholics to be selective in their adherence to the Church's moral teachings. It is sometimes claimed that dissent from the Magisterium is totally compatible with being a "good Catholic" and poses no obstacle to the reception of the sacraments. This is a grave error that challenges the teaching office of the bishops of the United States and elsewhere (my emphasis).6
So, the question, which had occupied the minds and hearts of married Catholics in the United States since the end of the Second Vatican Council in 1965, had finally been answered by the highest authority in the Church in 1987. Can a Catholic use contraceptives and continue to receive Holy Communion? The Pope’s answer was clear and succinct. No. And, those who go to Communion while dissenting from the Pope in the area of "conjugal morality" (e.g., contraception) are making a "grave error." Grave indeed! The Catechism of the Catholic Church says in no. 2120: “Sacrilege consists in profaning or treating unworthily the sacraments . . .” ( and that ) “Sacrilege is a grave sin especially when committed against the Eucharist.”

Archbishop Quinn’s question and John Paul II’s reply was published by the National Conference of Catholic Bishops in a book celebrating the Pope’s visit. But there seemed to be no mention of it by the American bishops in the Catholic media. This was very strange. First of all the American bishops did not ordinarily preach on contraception. Then John Paul II came to the United States and finally answered a serious question about contraception and Holy Communion that was on the hearts and minds of almost every married Catholic. But the bishops remained silent.

So why did the American bishops fail to communicate the Pope’s answer to American Catholics? Eugene Kennedy’s words might help explain this silence of the American bishops:
The American bishops repeatedly pledged their loyalty to the pope but dealt with birth control, as they do to this very day, as a pastoral rather than a disciplinary matter. The issue gradually moved away from being a test of public authority in the church to being the proper concern of the theologically informed private conscience.7
But, did this silence of the American bishops help the laity to come to a “theologically informed private conscience”? On the contrary, this silence made a correct formation of conscience even more difficult for the laity by leaving them ignorant of the Pope’s answer to a pressing moral question on contraception and Holy Communion. This decision seemed more like a political decision by churchmen than a “pastoral” decision by shepherds of the Church. Catholics in the United States simply did not hear about the Archbishop’s question and the Pope’s response to adequately form their conscience. Many Catholics probably continued to use contraceptives and receive Communion because they didn’t know any better. And the laity probably still don’t know any better today in 2008!

Paul VI's Warning Comes True

Forty years after Humanae Vitae we see that Paul VI was a prophet. The problem of pornography has reached epidemic proportions with the help of the internet. Images of men and women brazenly performing sexual acts, in the movies, television, and especially the internet, plague the minds of many in our society. Instances of divorce and remarriage, and men and women simply living together without a ceremony, have sky rocketed. Hideous crimes against women have become common place. Paul VI’s prophecies, that contraception could lead to a “lowering of moral standards” and that “man . . . may finally loose respect for the women,” have come to pass.

But more than this has occurred. Just as there is a link between love and life when sex is used according to God’s plan, so there is a link between lust and death when sex is used contrary to God’s plan. Murder has always been used to conceal the rape of a woman. Today abortion is used to conceal fornication and adultery. What is more, this complete disregard for life and love has invited perverted adults to prey on boys and girls. Divorce and remarriage has led to alternate marriage life styles in which substitute moms and dads are molesting, raping and murdering children. New born babies and toddlers are now found dead in boxes on rivers, in trash bins and in rest rooms. What use to be an exceptional horrific tragedy is now often reported in the daily news. Just as there is a clear connection between pornography and the degradation of women, so there is a connection between unbridled sex and violence. America says that it loves women and children, yet it permits this multi-billion dollar industry of pornography to thrive.

And now some cities and states in America have ruled that the Church must cover the cost of contraceptive pills (which are also abortifacients) in the health insurance plans of its employees.8 Once more, some states are requiring Catholic hospitals to dispense the contraceptive / abortifacient morning after pill to victims of rape, or at least to direct the victims to where they can obtain such a pill.9 While these contraceptive pills might prevent some pregnancies following a rape, many times they will be used as an abortifacient by women who have had promiscuous sex. Thus, the civil society is demanding that people, including the Church, at least cooperate in the murder of children in the womb, either by paying for the insurance cost of the murder or by directing a woman to where she can obtain the murder weapon (the pill). So, Paul VI’s final prophecy about the danger of accepting contraception, that rulers would “impose their use” upon their peoples, is also coming true.

Consequences and Silence over Contraception

The fact, that the American hierarchy (with some exceptions) did not emphatically and publicly teach the American people that contraception is evil, coarsened and debased society. This silence has left the Church’s teaching of the Gospel of Life and Love without its initial teaching or launching point. This is like teaching someone to fly a plane without teaching him how to take off. Just as the plane will crash at take off, so the attempt by the Church in the United States to teach the Gospel of Life and Love has failed from the very beginning. Let’s explain this further.

Paul VI taught that there is an “inseparable connection” between the “unitive significance and the procreative significance which are both inherent to the marriage act.”10 In other words, the purpose of the act of sexual intercourse in marriage is “life” and “love,” and these are inseparable.11 Consequently, when one disregards this unity of life and love in marriage by trying to separate life from love through contraception in order to have sex with one’s partner in married life, one loses both life and love and makes the act of having sex an absolute value. It absolutely identifies consensual sex with love (only forced sex, like rape, is not love). Once a person adopts this notion that having sex is an absolute value, then the person needs no other justification to have sex with whomever he or she wishes. The act of sex is absolutely justified. It is its own justification. It’s like shaking hands. All acts of sex are then automatically justified – adultery, fornication, pornography, masturbation, homosexual unions, even incest. Thus the bishops’ silence on the evil of contraception, has made it difficult, if not impossible, to successfully convince Americans that other more vile sexual acts are evil. So we are left with a sex saturated society.

The consequence of silence over contraception and Holy Communion

Nor did the American bishops teach the American people emphatically that practicing contraception is “an obstacle to the reception of the sacraments,” especially Holy Communion. If receiving Holy Communion while using contraceptives is a “grave error,” as the Pope says, then the silence by the bishops on this matter was a catastrophe. Let’s take a closer look at this. The bishops’ silence about John Paul II’s teaching, which forbids people who use contraceptives from receiving Holy Communion, jeopardized both the Bread of Life and Love and the Gospel of Life and Love. The bishops’ silence about John Paul II’s teaching left the door wide open for non believers and non practicing Catholics to commit sacrileges by receiving Communion unworthily. These sacrilegious communions in turn damaged the proclamation of the Gospel of Life and Love. It was no mere coincidence that, as the number of pro contraception, pro abortion, and pro gay rights people coming to Holy Communion increased in the Church following the 1960's, so did the number of acts of sex and violence against women and children increase in society.

These sacrilegious communions should never have happened. St. Paul is abundantly clear when he says in 1 Cor. 11: 27-29 that “whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord unworthily sins against the body and blood of the Lord . . . He who eats and drinks without recognizing the body eats and drinks a judgment on himself.” As far back as the second century the early Church excluded non believers and non practicing Christians from Holy Communion. The Church quotes second century St. Justin Martyr as saying: “No one may share the Eucharist with us unless he believes that what we teach is true, unless he is washed in the regenerating waters of baptism for the remission of his sins, and unless he lives in accordance with the principles given us by Christ.”12 And, Canon 915 of the Church’s present Code of Canon Law states “those who obstinately persist in manifest grave sin are not to be admitted to Holy Communion.” And Canon 916 states that “A person who is conscious of grave sin is not to celebrate Mass or to receive the Body of he Lord without prior sacramental confession.”

It is obvious that the Church’s devotion and reverence to the Bread of Life and Love will seriously affect the proclamation of the Gospel of Life and Love among Catholics in the United States. No one can authentically proclaim the Gospel of Life and Love without stopping abuses to the Bread of Life and Love. Someone may ask: To what extent must the Church go to protect the Bread of Life from abuse? Must we embarrass ourselves and others by refusing publically known pro abortion and pro gay rights politician from Holy Communion? The Church has considered questions like this since the early centuries. One example from a poem attributed to Pope Damasus I (366-384 AD) tells of St. Tarsicius who brought Viaticum to Christians about to die for their faith during the first centuries of Christianity. Tarsicius was murdered because he would not hand over the Blessed Sacrament to the Roman Soldiers who tried to take the Sacrament from him. To what extent must we defend the Bread of Life? We must defend the Bread of Life with our own life.13

A battle for life and love

Today American churchmen often ridicule prophets of gloom and doom who warn that God is about to punish people for their many sins. These churchmen think that God does not go around the world punishing people. They consider this an idea from the Middle Ages. Rather, they say, the problems of our times are really due to mismanagement and when we get the right people using the right formulas everything will be brought to good order again. But these churchmen must answer a very serious question: Do they believe the Sacred Scriptures and particularly St. Paul when he says about “fornication, uncleanness, passion, evil desires, and that lust which is idolatry” that “these are the sins which provoke God’s wrath”? If they do, then the sex-saturated society of the United States ought to be in for a real innundation of “God’s wrath.” Or has it already begun? Perhaps the presence of so many domestic murders, the daily discovery of dead bodies (especially children), the disharmony and viciousness among peoples, the failing economy, AIDS, clergy sexual abuse of the young, shortage of vocations, and the closing of parishes, all indicate that God has already begun to pour out his wrath upon us. Perhaps God has permitted these things because the Church did not protect the “Bread of Life” from sacrilege and the people from immorality. The Church should have pointed out to the people the evils of our time, particularly contraception.

One has to consider that the “lowering of moral standards” during our time is in danger of leading to one of the greatest moral collapse of any nation in history. The abandonment of moral values in the United States due to the social acceptance of contraception has even led to the social acceptance of homosexual marriage. As of May 15, 2008 California has become the second state after Massachusetts to legalize same sex marriage.14 In fact the growing number of people practicing homosexuality is strange in itself. Why now? What is causing this plague of radical deviancy in matters of human sexuality and this plague of abnormal sexual development? This explosion of same sex activity today resembles the moral collapse of the Roma Empire which was already occurring at the time of St. Paul. Every depraved act mentioned by St. Paul in his letter to the Romans is occurring in the United States today. St. Paul says:
In consequence, God delivered them up in their lusts to unclean practices; they engaged in the mutual degradation of their bodies, . . . God therefore delivered them up to disgraceful passions. Their women exchanged natural intercourse for unnatural, and the men gave up natural intercourse with women and burned with lust for one another. Men did shameful things with men, and thus received in their own persons the penalty for their perversity. They did not see fit to acknowledge God, so God delivered them up to their own depraved sense to do what is unseemly. They are filled with every kind of wickedness: maliciousness, greed, ill will, envy, murder, bickering, deceit, craftiness. They are gossips and slanderers, they hate God, are insolent, haughty, boastful, ingenious in their wrongdoing and rebellious toward their parents. One sees in them men without conscience, without loyalty, without affection, without pity. They know God’s just decree that all who do such things deserve death: yet they not only do them but approve them in others (Rom. 1:24-32).
Note the sentence, “They did not see fit to acknowledge God, so God delivered them up to their own depraved sense to do what is unseemly.” So, God permitted their own senses to draw them into homosexual activity because they did not acknowledge Him. In light of this revelation from St. Paul one cannot help wondering about the eruption and rapid spread of same sex activity in America today. Has God “delivered... up” Americans to the practice of homosexuality since “they did not see fit to acknowledge God?” Americans call these differences over sexual practices cultural battles. But, the fathers of the Church called these differences spiritual battles between good and evil. Catholics in America must realize that we are in the midst of a battle between good and evil over life and love.

Some Catholics think that it is too late to win this battle. They say that today is very similar to the times of Noah and Lot (Sodom and Gomorrah) in the Bible. Just as the people of Noah’s time were murders of children and the people of Lot’s time practiced all kinds of lust, particularly homosexuality, so today abortion and all kinds of illicit sexual activity, especially homosexual unions, abound (Gen. 4:23-24, 19:5). And just as God punished the people at the times of Noah and Lot with flood and fire and saved the good by means of an Ark and escaping the city of Sodom and Gomorrah, so God will deal the same way with America today (Gen. 6-9, 18:16-19:29).

The story of Noah and Lot, however, would only apply to people in the United States today if the Gospel of Life and Love had been completely proclaimed in America. God does not condemn someone for not knowing the Gospel – only for rejecting it (Mt.10:14-15). But the Gospel of Life and Love has not been completely proclaimed in America thanks to the silence of the American bishops.

Thus, we must also consider the biblical story of Jonah and Nineveh. Nineveh too had become evil but God knew that Nineveh would repent if a prophet spoke the truth fearlessly to them. So God chose Jonah to travel through Nineveh and warn the people that, if they did not repent of their sins, Nineveh would be destroyed in 40 days. Jonah was afraid to preach and tried to escape from the responsibility by hiding in a boat. A storm arose on the sea and when the crew realized that the problem was Jonah, they pitched Jonah overboard and the storm ceased. A whale swallowed Jonah and spit him up on the shore of Nineveh. So Jonah had to preach to the towns of Nineveh after all. When Jonah finally did preach, the people of Nineveh from greatest to smallest repented and God forgave their sins. God did not destroy Nineveh (Jonah 1-3).

The situation of Church in the United States is more like the situation of Jonah and Nineveh than Noah and Lot. Like Jonah, the Church in the United States hesitated to preach the Gospel of Life and Love within its own sex saturated society, particularly after John Paul II’s visit in 1987. The Church in the United States still seems to be hiding in the boat of “private conscience” or in the whale of “pastoral” solutions. This silence has caused a violent storm to arise. Only a complete proclamation of the Church’s teachings on human sexuality will calm this storm.

A complete proclamation requires “Holy” Communions

So, what is a complete proclamation of the Gospel of Life and Love? This is a proclamation of the Gospel of Life and Love which begins with the Church’s teaching on the purpose of human sexuality and the evil of contraception. The Church must begin her proclamation with this. The Church can then consistently point out that the more vile acts against life and love are evil. This would include acts such as: abortion, homosexual acts, adultery, divorce and remarriage, fornication, premarital sex, pornography, masturbation, and incest. When the purpose of human sexuality and the evil of contraception are explained, Catholics will see why these other more vile acts are evil.

This battle for life and love in the United States, however, cannot be won by any craft that we possess. St. Paul says: “For our struggle is not with flesh and blood but with the principalities, with the powers, with the world rulers of this present darkness, with the evil spirits in the heavens” (Eph 6:12). This battle can only be won by Jesus Christ. What Jesus Christ wants from us is “Holy” Communions. Consequently, People must be told from the pulpit repeatedly and regularly not to come to Communion if they are doing acts condemned by the Church, particularly contraception. The Church must point these sins out specifically. And if people are publicly known sinners, they must be turned away from Holy Communion. But, if the Church proclaims her teachings on human sexuality regularly and completely, we can hope that very few if any of these public sinners will dare to receive the Eucharist. “Holy” Communions will replace sacrilegious communions.

Once this Gospel of Life and Love is proclaimed completely, or is at least well under way, we will see whether or not Americans accept these teachings and whether the United States, like Nineveh, will be spared. If Americans reject the Gospel of Life and Love, then you can “shake its dust from your feet,” “flee to the mountains,” or launch an Ark (Mt 10:14, 24:16). But, this will not happen. Most Americans surely want life and love, not lust and death. If the Catholic Church proclaims the Gospel of Life and Love completely to the people in the United States, America will be saved.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. John Paul II, Evangelium Vitae, no. 81.

1. Paul VI, Humane Vitae, no. 14.
2. Paul VI, no. 17.
3. Paul VI, no. 17.
4. Paul VI, no. 17.
5. Archbishop John R, Quinn, Unity In The Work of Service (United States Catholic Conference: Washington, D . C., 1987), p.142.
6. John Paul II, Unity In The Work of Service, p. 144.
7. Eugene Kennedy, Cardinal Bernardin (Chicago: Bonus Bks., Inc., 1989), p. 69.
8. Steven A. Holmes, “Congress and District Clash Over a New City Ordinance,” New York Times (July 14 2000); Editorial, “A Win for Contraception,” New York Times (June 16 2001).
9. Bills, Statutes and Legislation of different states: Arkansas Code # 20-13-1401, et. seq. (2007); Colorado Rev. Stat. 25-3-110(2007); Connecticut Public Act. No. 24(2007).
10. Paul VI, no. 12.
11. Paul VI, no. 9.
12. St. Justin Martyr, Liturgy of the Hours (Vol 2), Office of Readings for Third Sunday of Easter, Second Reading ( New York: Catholic Book Publishing Co., 1976), p. 694.
13. E. Day, “St. Tarsicius,” New Catholic Encyclopedia, Vol. 13 (New York: McGraw-Hill Bk. CO., 1967), p. 940.
14. Lisa Leff, “California Supreme Court overturns gay marriage ban,” The Associated Press, May 15, 2008.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Originally published in the March 2009 issue of Homiletic & Pastoral Review, p.30)
Download the printable version of this article in PDF format: American Can Still Be Saved. Permission is hereby granted to reproduce this article.






 

0 comments:

  © Blogger template Autumn Leaves by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP